I wonder why they decided to limit the stories to relatively recent ones, rather than the more "classic" sf tales on that particular subject...?
| Author | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Custer1 |
Re: Anthologies | ||
|
I see that the site gives the entire text of the Cory Doctorow story, and a link to a podcast version!
I wonder why they decided to limit the stories to relatively recent ones, rather than the more "classic" sf tales on that particular subject...? |
|||
ljim2000 |
Re: Anthologies | ||
|
I'm currently reading The Altered I: Ursula K. Le Guin's Science Fiction Writing Workshop edited by Lee Harding. This anthology is the product of a one week workshop Le Guin held in Australia in 1975 (with all emerging Australian writers.)
Reading it is very interesting if a bit like reading a textbook at times. There are almost as many essays about the whole experience as there are stories, and there is even a Le Guin story to start things out completely critiqued by the workshop members. It's kind of interesting to read and enjoy a story for what it is, to find it next torn to pieces and dissected by a group who know the author is seriously considering what is being said. Fun to play a Google "Where Are They Now" with some of the writers: Randal Flynn has spent some time in the UK since and sold film scripts to Hollywood it seems as well as working with Douglas Adams on Doctor Who; Stefan Vucak is reportedly working on his fifth hard SF novel; Kitty Vigo has a rather extensive history of editing and educational endeavors, as recently as 1996 Petrina Smith was a nominee in the World Fantasy Award category of Short Fiction as well as having a continuing searchable output of SF short stories; and so on... |
|||
Custer1 |
Re: Anthologies | ||
|
And Lee Harding himself has had quite a busy sf career - I thought the name was familiar! He was a contributor to New Worlds and Science Fantasy, and has been a major figure in Australian sf for decades, being awarded the 2006 A. Bertram Chandler Award, I see... his Wikipedia page lists 13 novels, as well as three anthologies.
|
|||
ljim2000 |
Re: | ||
|
That's cool. None of the writers have achieved Wikipedia entries yet that I could find.
|
|||
eldritch00 |
Re: The New Space Opera | ||
|
The criticisms mentioned at the beginning of this review are heartbreaking to read, especially because it does accurately point to a lot of problems in the genre at large and not just this anthology...but stick with it, as it all gets better in the end when Alan de Niro concludes that The New Space Opera is still an anthology worth purchasing.
|
|||
ljim2000 |
Re: The New Space Opera | ||
|
Here's a really cool idea that intrigues me to no end! The SFWA European Hall of Fame is an anthology of all stories translated from non-English speaking continental European countries ranging from 1987 to 2005.
|
|||
Custer1 |
Re: The New Space Opera | ||
Quote: I'm glad the reviewer got won round in the end. As for the "European Hall of Fame", that seems a pretty big name/claim to put on an anthology, but the collection does seem like a good idea. |
|||
pecooper |
Re: The New Space Opera | ||
|
True. We Americans tend forget that there's a whole world out there. We tend to see Canadian SF as exotic. Let's bring on the Europeans. And the Indians, too.
|
|||
etaisback |
Re: Anthologies | ||
|
I found a site discussing Gakaxy, one of the best
http://extrasolar.spaceart.org/galaxymagazine/interview_01152000_lynettecook.html eta was here disguised as etaisback or piemur of Pern; Tally ho!
|
|||
Custer1 |
Re: Anthologies | ||
|
Hmm, I wonder why ezboard didn't make that a link? Different message board systems do different things, I bet the oncoming change to Yuku makes it one. It's a shame that "galaxy online" is a dead site now, following the link to the front page just gets one to a "domain for sale" page.
Well, I guess this would have gone just as well in the "internet" section, or "magazines", since Galaxy was a well-known and much-loved sf print magazine for many decades, but hey, there were quite a few anthologies from it over the years, usually with a title like "The Seventh Galaxy Reader" if I remember rightly.
|
|||
ljim2000 |
Re: Anthologies | ||
|
I've just started reading an anthology called (and I don't really like this title at all) The Mammoth Book of Extreme Science Fiction New Generation Far-Future SF edited by Mike Ashley.
Ashley puts forth the idea that there is a sub-genre he dubs "extreme science fiction" that I am hard pressed to figure out how it is different from the root genre. He definitely favors hard SF, and that with really big ideas, and makes the distinction that "extreme SF" isn't avant-garde literature in any fashion (which I thin some of the authors in his collection might dispute). It says something about his concept and how well it has (not) caught on, that when you google "extreme science fiction" the first two pages are entirely about his book. Regardless, he has certainly collected a great bunch of solid authors to read, which is why I checked out the book: Charles Stross with Cory Doctorow, Robert Reed, Alastair Reynolds, Greg Bear, Gregory Benford, Harlan Ellison, Theodore Sturgeon, Paul Di Fillipo, Ian McDonald, Clifford D. Simak, and others. I do note, not a lot of female writers, but he at least acknowledges this on the introduction to Pat Cadigan's story. She's likely the only female author in the whole collection unless B. Vallance was a woman as well (this one dates from 1909 and Ashley is upfront that he doesn't know a thing about the author!) He writes snappy little intros for each of the authors as well, which are nice, if overly tied to his questionable theme. |
|||
Custer1 |
Re: Anthologies | ||
|
There have been lots of "Mammoth Book" anthologies, I don't know if it is a single brand or not, but as well as sf they cover a broad spectrum. using that as a search term at Amazon brings up 1920 results, but some duplication may be involved...
|
|||
ljim2000 |
Re: Anthologies | ||
|
Yes, it looks like Mike Ashley is at least usually the editor too. He obviously reads a whole lot, since he seems to really know the authors well.
|
|||
Custer1 |
Re: Anthologies | ||
Quote: That, sadly, was about the top search result when I searched for the obvious title. But yes, Mike Ashley does seem to be involved usually. |
|||
ljim2000 |
Re: Anthologies | ||
|
I like the idea of a book devoted to the furry ancestors of elephants, but perhaps "The Mammoth Book of Mastodons" would be a less redundant title...
|
|||
Custer1 |
Re: Anthologies | ||
|
I don't know why it has to be mammoths to denote great bulk, but somehow "The Mastodon Book of Mammoths" just doesn't have the same cachet.
|
|||
ljim2000 |
Re: Anthologies | ||
|
A short story anthology is proving to be a great book for rearing a newborn. I only get a few small pages at a time, so it's nice for that to amount to a significant part of a given story.
|
|||
ljim2000 |
Re: Anthologies | ||
|
Well, I read the collaboration between Charles Stross and Cory Doctorow, "Flowers from Alice" and it was definitely an odd experience a bit like reading a composite of both men's styles. The protagonist makes a living writing a blog, so that definitely brought Doctorow's mindset to the forefront. The ending is rather confusing and I wonder if they were tag-teaming that part a great deal. The whole story is about post-humanism and so the "marriage" at the end has some very strange convolutions of pronouns that I didn't entirely follow. I'm not sure if I was supposed to or not though.
|
|||
Custer1 |
Re: Anthologies | ||
|
I see that Cory D describes it as "a pervy piece of post-Singularity erotica", if that is any help...
|
|||
ljim2000 |
Re: Anthologies | ||
|
That descriptions seems a little, er, extreme...
|
|||